Suggestions
Journal Information
Cite
Cite
Share
Download PDF
More article options
Visits
537
Original Article
Full text access

Low awareness of HIV status and high proportion of recent infections among young travestis and trans women in Brazil

Visits
537
Emilia M. Jalila,
Corresponding author
, Carolina Coutinhoa, Thaylla Wargasa, Camila Santosa, Carolina Ribeiro Arsolinoa, Neilane Bertonib, Isabele Barbosa Mouraa, Cristiane R.V. Castroa, Ronaldo Ismerio Moreiraa, Brenda Hoaglanda, Sandra W. Cardosoa, Laylla Monteiroa, Sylvia L.M. Teixeirac, Valdilea G. Velosoa, Thiago S. Torresa, Beatriz Grinsztejna, Erin C. Wilsond,1
a Instituto Nacional de Infectologia Evandro Chagas, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz (INI-Fiocruz), Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
b Instituto Nacional do Câncer (INCA), Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
c Instituto Oswaldo Cruz, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz (IOC-Fiocruz), Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
d San Francisco Department of Public Health, San Francisco, USA
This item has received
Article information
Abstract
Full Text
Bibliography
Download PDF
Statistics
Tables (5)
Table 1. Sociodemographics, sexual behavior, and HIV knowledge among young trans women in BeT study, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.
Tables
Table 2. Gender transition characteristics among young trans women in BeT study in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.
Tables
Table 3. Health, STI, and behavior characteristics among young trans women in BeT study in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.
Tables
Table 4. Knowledge, stigma, and mental health characteristics among young trans women in BeT study in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.
Tables
Table 5. Multivariable model of factors associated with a new HIV diagnosis among young trans women in BeT study, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.
Tables
Additional material (1)
Abstract
Introduction

This study examined correlates of new HIV diagnosis (i.e., no prior awareness of HIV-positive status and HIV diagnosis at study entry) and identified factors associated with HIV vulnerability among Brazilian young trans women.

Material and methods

Baseline assessment of Brilhar e Transcender (BeT [“Shine and Transcend” in English]), an HIV status-neutral intervention single-center study using peer-led digital and in-person systems navigation, between February‒July 2022, in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Trans women aged 18‒24 years, living in Rio de Janeiro city or the metropolitan area, were eligible if they were not currently on HIV Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) for those who were HIV-negative, or if they were not on antiretroviral therapy, had a detectable viral load, or were not linked to HIV care for those living with HIV.

Results

Among 170 potential participants, 164 young trans women were eligible and enrolled. Among these, 13% (n = 22) were living with HIV, 68% of them (n = 15) were unaware of their HIV status and diagnosed with HIV; 33% (n = 4 of 12) had a recent HIV infection. Overall, 23.1% had current syphilis, 15% rectal chlamydia, and 13% rectal gonorrhea. Younger age (18‒19 years) (adjusted Odds Ratio [aOR=5.62], 95% Confidence Interval [95% CI 1.36‒27.22]), lower educational attainment (aOR = 7.99, 95% CI 1.78‒47.85), and moderate/high risk of crack/cocaine use (aOR = 8.6, 95% CI 1.44‒54.91) were associated with a higher odds of a new HIV diagnosis.

Conclusions

HIV disparities among young trans women in Brazil reflect persistent structural and social inequities shaping vulnerability and access. Tailored interventions must extend prevention efforts beyond individual behaviors to address these broader determinants.

Keywords:
Brazil
HIV care
HIV prevention
Peer-led digital intervention
Trans women
Youth
Full Text
Introduction

Trans women face extraordinary risk for HIV, with prevalence reaching levels as high as 49.6%.1 A critical public health challenge is how to prevent new infections among adult and young trans women. Longitudinal research measuring the HIV incidence of trans women in the U.S found young age was a predictor, suggesting that current efforts are insufficient to eradicate HIV in the next generation of young trans women.2 Increasing attacks on transgender populations, particularly regarding access to gender-affirming care and HIV prevention, risk worsening existing health disparities as health access and prioritization is affected.3

Since 2000, Latin America has made important gains in expanding access to HIV prevention and treatment. Brazil is the largest country in the region and offers effective HIV prevention and care at no direct cost to users through its National Public Health System (SUS). Despite advancements, the region has seen limited progress in reducing new HIV acquisitions.4 From 2010 to 2023, the number of new HIV infections in Brazil increased by 9%. Persistent challenges in reducing new HIV acquisitions in key populations like young sexual and gender minority communities, including trans women, are part of why new infections are on the rise.4 Prior research conducted in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil found that one-third-of trans women were living with HIV, and 25% of young trans women were already living with HIV by age 24.5 Although oral Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) has been available in the country since 2017, only 4.5% of those currently using it are transgender people, predominantly those aged 30-years or older.6 Low PrEP utilization and poor outcomes along the PrEP continuum in Brazil7,8 highlight the urgent need to identify factors associated with new HIV infections among young trans women.

Discrimination and violence are key drivers of mental health disorders and sexual risk behaviors among trans women,5,9 contributing to HIV vulnerability through syndemic conditions such as depression, substance use, and social marginalization.10,11 Research in the US has found that experiences of bullying, trauma, mental distress and parental rejection are correlated with engagement in sexual risk behaviors and HIV status among trans youth.12 However, few studies have been conducted in Latin America with young trans women to explore their elevated vulnerability to HIV and determine factors most closely associated with risk for acquiring HIV.

In this study, we examined the correlates of new HIV diagnosis and identified factors associated with vulnerability to HIV among young trans women aged 18‒24 years in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. The goal of this analysis was to uncover factors to target interventions tailored to young trans women to curb the ever-growing epidemic in the population and region.

Material and methodsStudy design and participants

We analyzed data from the baseline assessment of Brilhar e Transcender (BeT [“Shine and Transcend” in English]) study, an adapted evidence-based, HIV status-neutral intervention study using peer-led digital and in-person systems navigation, conducted in the Instituto Nacional de Infectologia Evandro Chagas ‒ Fiocruz (INI-Fiocruz), in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, between February‒July 2022. Study procedures have been described elsewhere.13 The study was part of eight sponsored research projects chosen to be a part of a Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development ‒ funded Prevention and Treatment through a Comprehensive Care Continuum for HIV-affected Adolescents in Resource Constrained Settings (PATC3H) consortium. This trial was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov NCT05299645; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT05299645.

Our site at INI-Fiocruz is a referral center that provides comprehensive, gender-affirming, and stigma-sensitive care for transgender individuals within a multidisciplinary HIV framework. Participants were recruited from those receiving HIV care or prevention at our clinical site or were referred by our Community Education Team, partners from non-governmental organizations and other health units. Eligibility criteria were: 1) Male sex assigned at birth and self-identification as travesti, transgender woman, or within the trans feminine spectrum, 2) Ages between 18- and 24-years, 3) Living in Rio de Janeiro city or its metropolitan area, and 4) Sexually active. Throughout this manuscript, we use the term “trans women” to refer to participants of all gender identities included in the study. Additional criteria for young trans women not living with HIV were 1) No current PrEP use, 2) PrEP indication according to the Brazilian recommendations at the time of the study, and 3) No PrEP contraindication. For participants living with HIV, additional inclusion criteria were 1) Confirmed HIV diagnosis, 2) No current Antiretroviral Therapy (ART) use or a detectable Viral Load (VL) or not linked to HIV care. Exclusion criteria were: 1) Participation in any HIV prevention or care intervention study in the last year, 2) Refusal to undergo HIV testing, or 3) Having any health condition that, in the opinion of the investigator, precludes participation in the study or may lead to harm to the participant. After eligibility assessment, participants were enrolled and followed for 48-weeks.

Procedures

At study entry, participants responded to trained interviewer-administered surveys, including a screening questionnaire and demographic information after providing written consent. Participants were tested for HIV, syphilis, rectal Chlamydia Trachomatis (CT), and rectal Neisseria Gonorrhea (NG). Participants reporting recent anal condomless sex (<30-days) with a negative HIV rapid test were screened for acute HIV infection through VL testing. Recent HIV acquisitions were identified using the Maxim HIV-1 Lag-Avidity EIA assay as part of Recent Infection Testing Algorithm (RITA), following previous studies.14–16 Syphilis screening was conducted using treponemal testing, followed by Venereal Disease Laboratory Testing (VDRL) if the former test yielded a positive result. Hepatitis B and C were first screened using rapid tests followed by serology assessments, if needed.

Study outcomes and definitions

Data were analyzed by grouping participants into three categories: HIV-negative, with a known HIV diagnosis, and with a new HIV diagnosis (i.e., participants who were previously unaware of their HIV status and received an HIV diagnosis at study entry). We collected information on education as a continuous variable and categorized educational attainment into: “up to 8-years” (incomplete elementary school), “9‒11 years” (incomplete secondary school), and “12-years or more” (complete secondary school or more). Unstable housing was defined as living in a shelter or institution, transitional housing, as a guest in someone else's home, at a workplace, in a motel/hotel/inn, or other temporary arrangements. Food insecurity was assessed using an adapted version of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations questions.17 Ever syphilis was defined as a positive treponemal test at study entry. Current syphilis was defined as a positive treponemal test with a reactive VDRL, subsequently confirmed as active syphilis by clinical adjudication performed by a study physician. We assessed crack/cocaine use through the Alcohol, Smoking and Substance Involvement Screening Test (ASSIST) scale and classified into ‘low risk’ and ‘moderate/high risk’ use.18 HIV knowledge was assessed using an adapted HIV Knowledge Questionnaire-10 with 8-items.19,20 We used the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test for alcohol consumption (3-items) to assess alcohol use.21 Substance use was defined as use of any illicit substance as marijuana, cocaine (powder, crack, or paste), ecstasy, LSD, MDMA, methamphetamine, ketamine, poppers or other inhalants. Social support was assessed using Multidimensional Scale of Perceived Social Support, and evaluated overall, from friends, from family, and from partner.22 We screened the following mental health issues: 1) Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) using the Primary Care PTSD scale (positive screening: score ≥ 4),23 2) Depression and anxiety using the Patient Health Questionnaire for Depression and Anxiety scale (positive screening: positive if scores ≥ 3).24 Participants were considered with HIV recent acquisition if the final LAg ODn of the avidity assay was ≤ 1.5, VL > 400 copies/mL, CD4 count >200 cells/mm3, and absence or no history of an AIDS-defining illness, all according to data obtained from Brazilian national information systems.

Statistical analysis

Descriptive statistics included median with Interquartile Ranges (IQRs), and absolute and relative frequencies, overall and according to HIV status. Univariable and multivariable logistic regression models were used to assess factors associated with new HIV diagnosis, using HIV-negative participants as the reference group. All variables with p-value <0.25 in the univariable analysis were included in the initial multivariable model, adjusted for race, transactional sex, fillers, and binge drinking. Model fit was assessed using the Hosmer-Lemeshow test, and residual normality was evaluated with the Shapiro-Wilk test. The final model was selected based on overall fit quality. All analyses were performed on the R project version 4.2.3.

Ethical considerations

This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board at the INI-Fiocruz; CAAE #05018818.0.0000.5262) and the University of California, San Francisco Committee on Human Research (#18-26770) in accordance with all applicable regulations. All participants provided written informed consent prior to any study procedure.

Results

Among 170 potential participants, 164 young trans women were eligible and enrolled in the study, and six were ineligible. Among those enrolled, 13% (n = 22) were living with HIV. Among these, 68% (n = 15) were unaware of their HIV status and were diagnosed with HIV at enrollment. We evaluated HIV recency in 12 out of the 15 participants with new HIV diagnosis (3 had no sample available); 33% of them (n = 4 of 12) had a recent HIV acquisition. Overall, median age was 21-years (interquartile range: 19‒22), most participants identified as Black (38%) or Pardo/mixed (26%), and 59% reported food insecurity (Table 1). Median age of identifying a gender different than assigned at birth was 13-years, while the median age of gender transition was 18-years. A large majority of participants had used Gender-Affirming Hormone Therapy (GAHT) at some point (85%), with most using non-prescribed hormones (92%). While none had undergone gender-affirming bottom surgery, 38% expressed a desire to have it in the future. A small percentage (9.8%) reported using industrial fillers (Table 2).

Table 1.

Sociodemographics, sexual behavior, and HIV knowledge among young trans women in BeT study, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.

  Total(n = 164)  HIV new diagnosis,n = 15 (9.1%)  HIV negative,n = 142 (86.6%)  HIV known diagnosis,n = 7 (4.3%) 
Age, years (median [IQR])  21 (19; 23)  21 (19; 22)  21 (20; 23)  23 (21; 24) 
Age category, years (%)         
18‒19  43 (26.2%)  6 (40.0%)  35 (24.6%)  2 (28.6%) 
20‒22  74 (45.1%)  6 (40.0%)  68 (47.9%)  0 (0.0%) 
23‒24  47 (28.7%)  3 (20.0%)  39 (27.5%)  5 (71.4%) 
Gender identity         
Travesti  34 (20.7%)  0 (0.0%)  33 (23.2%)  1 (14.3%) 
Transgender women  123 (75.0%)  15 (100.0%)  104 (73.2%)  4 (57.1%) 
Women  4 (2.4%)  0 (0.0%)  2 (1.4%)  2 (28.6%) 
Other identities  3 (1.8%)  0 (0.0%)  3 (2.1%)  0 (0.0%) 
Race         
Black  63 (38.7%)  6 (40.0%)  57 (40.1%)  0 (0.0%) 
Pardo/Mixed  42 (25.8%)  4 (26.7%)  35 (24.6%)  3 (42.9%) 
White  55 (33.7%)  5 (33.3%)  46 (32.4%)  4 (57.1%) 
Indigenous  1 (0.6%)  0 (0.0%)  1 (0.7%)  0 (0.0%) 
Asian  2 (1.2%)  0 (0.0%)  2 (1.4%)  0 (0.0%) 
Missing 
City         
Rio de Janeiro  121 (73.8%)  8 (53.3%)  109 (76.8%)  4 (57.1%) 
Other  43 (26.2%)  7 (46.7%)  33 (23.2%)  3 (42.9%) 
Schooling (complete years)         
Up to 8-years  18 (11.0%)  5 (33.3%)  11 (7.7%)  2 (28.6%) 
9‒11 years  37 (22.7%)  4 (26.7%)  31 (21.8%)  2 (28.6%) 
12+ years  108 (66.3%)  6 (40.0%)  99 (69.7%)  3 (42.9%) 
Missing 
Currently studying  61 (37.2%)  3 (20.0%)  57 (40.1%)  1 (14.3%) 
Currently working  66 (40.2%)  7 (46.7%)  56 (39.4%)  3 (42.9%) 
Living with:a         
Alone  42 (25.6%)  3 (20.0%)  36 (25.4%)  3 (42.9%) 
Parents  68 (41.5%)  7 (46.7%)  60 (42.3%)  1 (14.3%) 
Family  29 (17.7%)  4 (26.7%)  25 (17.6%)  0 (0.0%) 
Partner  9 (5.5%)  1 (6.7%)  8 (5.6%)  0 (0.0%) 
Friends  15 (9.1%)  0 (0.0%)  14 (9.9%)  1 (14.3%) 
Other  8 (4.9%)  1 (6.7%)  5 (3.5%)  2 (28.6%) 
Housing         
Stable  148 (90.2%)  15 (100.0%)  129 (90.81%)  4 (57.1%) 
Unstable  16 (9.8%)  0 (0.0%)  13 (9.2%)  3 (42.9%) 
Concern with housing situationb         
Yes  45 (27.4%)  4 (26.7%)  38 (26.8%)  3 (42.9%) 
No  119 (72.6%)  11 (73.3%)  104 (73.2%)  4 (57.1%) 
Food insecurityc         
Yes  97 (59.1%)  7 (46.7%)  87 (61.3%)  3 (42.9%) 
No  67 (40.9%)  8 (53.3%)  55 (38.7%)  4 (57.1%) 

IQR, Interquartile Range, TGW, Trans Women.

a

Participants could report more than one category.

b

In prior 6-months.

c

In prior 3-months.

Table 2.

Gender transition characteristics among young trans women in BeT study in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.

  Total(n = 164)  HIV new diagnosisn = 15 (9.1%)  HIV negative,n = 142 (86.6%)  HIV known diagnosis,n = 7 (4.3%) 
Age of identifying with gender different from that assigned at birth (median [IQR])  13 (10‒16)  11 (10‒15)  14 (10‒16)  12 (8‒14) 
Age of gender transition (median [IQR])  18 (15‒19)  17 (15‒19)  18 (15‒19)  16 (15‒18) 
Ever GAHT use  139 (84.8%)  13 (86.7%)  120 (84.5%)  6 (85.7%) 
Non-prescribed hormone usea  129 (92.8%)  13 (100.0%)  110 (91.7%)  6 (100.0%) 
Current GAHT usea  95 (68.3%)  9 (69.2%)  85 (70.8%)  1 (16.7%) 
Gender-affirming bottom surgery         
Already performed it  0 (0.0%)  0 (0.0%)  0 (0.0%)  0 (0.0%) 
Want to perform it  63 (38.4%)  5 (33.3%)  56 (39.4%)  2 (28.6%) 
Don’t want to perform it  97 (59.1%)  10 (66.7%)  82 (57.7%)  5 (71.4%) 
Refused to answer  4 (2.4%)  0 (0.0%)  4 (2.8%)  0 (0.0%) 
Industrial filler  16 (9.8%)  3 (20.0%)  10 (7.0%)  3 (42.9%) 
a

Among those who ever used GAHT. GAHT, Gender-Affirming Hormone Therapy; IQR, Interquartile Range.

Prevalence of bacterial Sexually Transmitted Infections (bSTI) was high, with 23.1% presenting current active syphilis, 15% with rectal CT, and 13% with rectal NG (Table 3). No participant tested positive for hepatitis B (n = 0/163) or C (n = 0/160). A total of 70% engaged in condomless receptive anal sex in the last 6-months, and 49% ever engaged in transactional sex. Binge drinking and moderate/high risk of crack/cocaine use were reported by 74% and 9.1%, respectively. The majority of participants reported experiencing discrimination due to their gender identity (99%), with 83% having experienced verbal violence. A significant proportion screened positive for anxiety (44%), depression (32%), and PTSD (17%), and 59% reported ever attempting suicide. Furthermore, 44% reported avoiding healthcare assistance due to fear of discrimination and 32% were unaware of the meaning of ‘U = U’ (Undetectable = Untransmittable).

Table 3.

Health, STI, and behavior characteristics among young trans women in BeT study in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.

  Total(n = 164)  HIV new diagnosis,n = 15 (9%)  HIV negative,n = 142 (87%)  HIV known diagnosis,n = 7 (4%) 
Overall health rating         
Excellent  10 (6.1%)  2 (13.3%)  8 (5.6%)  0 (0.0%) 
Very good  19 (11.6%)  2 (13.3%)  16 (11.3%)  1 (14.3%) 
Good  80 (48.8%)  7 (46.7%)  70 (49.3%)  3 (42.9%) 
Reasonable  47 (28.7%)  3 (20.0%)  43 (30.3%)  1 (14.3%) 
Bad  5 (3.0%)  0 (0.0%)  4 (2.8%)  1 (14.3%) 
Don’t know  3 (1.8%)  1 (6.7%)  1 (0.7%)  1 (14.3%) 
Has private health insurance         
Yes  19 (11.6%)  2 (13.3%)  16 (11.3%)  1 (14.3%) 
No  145 (88.4%)  13 (86.7%)  126 (88.7%)  6 (85.7%) 
Ever tested for HIV         
Yes  117 (78.5%)  6 (85.7%)  110 (78.0%)  1 (100.0%) 
No  30 (20.1%)  1 (14.3%)  29 (20.6%)  0 (0.0%) 
Don't know  2 (1.3%)  0 (0.0%)  2 (1.4%)  0 (0.0%) 
Missinga  15 
Ever syphilis  61 (37.7%)  10 (66.7%)  45 (32.1%)  6 (85.7%) 
Missinga 
Current active syphilis  37 (23.1%)  5 (33.3%)  27 (19.6%)  5 (71.4%) 
Missinga 
Rectal chlamydia  24 (15.0%)  3 (20.0%)  21 (15.2%)  0 (0.0%) 
Missinga 
Rectal gonorrhea  21 (13.1%)  3 (20.0%)  18 (13.0%)  0 (0.0%) 
Missinga 
Known number of sex partners in the last 3-months         
Yes  128 (78.0%)  9 (60.0%)  115 (81.0%)  4 (57.1%) 
No  21 (12.8%)  5 (33.3%)  14 (9.9%)  2 (28.6%) 
Number of partners (median [IQR])b  3 (1‒5)  5 (3‒5)  3 (1‒5)  1 (1‒4) 
HIV knowledge scalec         
High  121 (73.8%)  8 (53.3%)  109 (76.8%)  4 (57.1%) 
Low  43 (26.2%)  7 (46.7%)  33 (23.2%)  3 (42.9%) 
Had condomless receptive anal sex in the last 6-months  115 (70.1%)  12 (80.0%)  98 (69.0%)  5 (71.4%) 
Transactional sex         
In the last 3-months  57 (34.8%)  8 (53.3%)  45 (31.7%)  4 (57.1%) 
Prior to 3-months  24 (14.6%)  2 (13.3%)  20 (14.1%)  2 (28.6%) 
Never  83 (50.6%)  5 (33.3%)  77 (54.2%)  1 (14.3%) 
Binge drinking  121 (73.8%)  13 (86.7%)  103 (72.5%)  5 (71.4%) 
Moderate/high risk of crack/cocaine use*  15 (9.1%)  4 (26.7%)  9 (6.3%)  2 (28.6%) 

IQR, Interquartile Range; TGW, Trans Women.

a

Missing data excluded from percentages.

b

Among those who knew the number of sexual partners.

c

HIV knowledge range: 0‒8; low knowledge: <6.

Compared to young trans women not living with HIV, those with a new HIV diagnosis were younger (40%vs. 25% aged 18- to 19-years). They also more frequently lived outside the main metropolitan area of Rio de Janeiro (47%vs. 23%) and had an incomplete elementary school education (33%vs. 7.8%) (Table 1). Less utilization of GAHT was observed among young trans women with a new HIV diagnosis (17%vs. 69%) and a higher proportion of industrial fillers’ use (43%vs. 20%) (Table 2). In addition, participants with a new HIV diagnosis more often reported transactional sex (66%vs. 46%), an unknown number of sexual partners (40%vs. 19%), and had lower HIV knowledge (47%vs. 23%) compared to those not living with HIV (Table 3). Regarding the ‘U = U’ message, a higher proportion of young trans women with a new HIV diagnosis were unaware of its meaning compared to those without HIV (67%vs. 30%) (Table 4). Multivariable analysis identified that individuals aged 18‒19 years (adjusted Odds Ratio [aOR=5.62], 95% Confidence Interval [95% CI 1.36‒27.22]), with lower educational attainment (aOR=7.99, 95% CI 1.78‒47.85), and those who reported moderate/high risk of crack/cocaine use (aOR=8.6, 95% CI 1.44‒54.91) had a higher odds of a new HIV diagnosis (Table 5).

Table 4.

Knowledge, stigma, and mental health characteristics among young trans women in BeT study in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.

  Total(n = 164)  HIV new diagnosis, n = 15 (9%)  HIV negative, n = 142 (87%)  HIV known diagnosis, n = 7 (4%) 
Ever disclosed gender identity  155 (94.5%)  15 (100.0%)  133 (93.7%)  7 (100.0%) 
Social support         
Friends         
High  97 (59.1%)  6 (40.0%)  86 (60.6%)  5 (71.4%) 
Medium  48 (29.3%)  7 (46.7%)  39 (27.5%)  2 (28.6%) 
Low  19 (11.6%)  2 (13.3%)  17 (12.0%)  0 (0.0%) 
Partner         
High  110 (67.1%)  10 (66.7%)  94 (66.2%)  6 (85.7%) 
Medium  44 (26.8%)  5 (33.3%)  38 (26.8%)  1 (14.3%) 
Low  10 (6.1%)  0 (0.0%)  10 (7.0%)  0 (0.0%) 
Family         
High  60 (36.6%)  6 (40.0%)  50 (35.2%)  4 (57.1%) 
Medium  64 (39.0%)  5 (33.3%)  58 (40.8%)  1 (14.3%) 
Low  40 (24.4%)  4 (26.7%)  34 (23.9%)  2 (28.6%) 
U = U knowledge         
Don’t know what it means  53 (32.3%)  10 (66.7%)  43 (30.3%)  0 (0.0%) 
Totally correct  67 (40.9%)  4 (26.7%)  60 (42.3%)  3 (42.9%) 
Somewhat correct  25 (15.2%)  1 (6.7%)  21 (14.8%)  3 (42.9%) 
Somewhat incorrect  12 (7.3%)  0 (0.0%)  12 (8.5%)  0 (0.0%) 
Totally incorrect  7 (4.3%)  0 (0.0%)  6 (4.2%)  1 (14.3%) 
Any discrimination due to gender identity  162 (98.8%)  15 (100.0%)  140 (98.6%)  7 (100.0%) 
Ever physical violence due to gender identity  61 (37.2%)  6 (40.0%)  52 (36.6%)  3 (42.9%) 
Ever verbal violence due to gender identity  136 (82.9%)  14 (93.3%)  117 (82.4%)  5 (71.4%) 
Avoided healthcare because of fear of being discriminated  72 (43.9%)  8 (53.3%)  63 (44.4%)  1 (14.3%) 
Health professionals refused to assist due to gender identity  12 (7.3%)  2 (13.3%)  10 (7.0%)  0 (0.0%) 
Treated badly/unfairly by healthcare professionals due to gender identity  30 (18.3%)  1 (6.7%)  27 (19.0%)  2 (28.6%) 
Healthcare professionals refused to discuss about issues of trans health  34 (20.7%)  1 (6.7%)  31 (21.8%)  2 (28.6%) 
Positive depression screening  52 (32.1%)  5 (33.3%)  46 (32.9%)  1 (14.3%) 
Missinga 
Positive anxiety screening  69 (43.7%)  6 (40.0%)  62 (45.3%)  1 (16.7%) 
Missinga 
Positive PTSD screening  28 (17.1%)  1 (6.7%)  25 (17.6%)  2 (28.6%) 
Ever sexual violence  58 (36.9%)  5 (33.3%)  49 (36.3%)  4 (57.1%) 
Missinga 
Ever sexual violence from partner  35 (22.0%)  3 (20.0%)  32 (23.4%)  0 (0.0%) 
Missinga 
Ever worried about safety from partner  70 (42.9%)  4 (26.7%)  65 (46.1%)  1 (14.3%) 
Missing 
Ever suicide attempt         
In the last 30-days  35 (21.3%)  3 (20.0%)  31 (21.8%)  1 (14.3%) 
Prior to 30-days  63 (38.4%)  5 (33.3%)  56 (39.4%)  2 (28.6%) 
Never  64 (39.0%)  7 (46.7%)  53 (37.3%)  4 (57.1%) 
Refused to answer  2 (1.2%)  0 (0.0%)  2 (1.4%)  0 (0.0%) 

IQR, Interquartile Range; PTSD, Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder.

a

Missing data excluded from percentages.

Table 5.

Multivariable model of factors associated with a new HIV diagnosis among young trans women in BeT study, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.

Variablesa  aOR  95%CI  p-value 
Age 18‒19 years (ref. 20‒24 years)  5.62  1.36‒27.22  0.021 
Race: Black/Mixed/Otherc (ref. white)  0.47  0.11‒1.9  0.276 
Schooling ≤ 8-years (ref. 12+ years)  7.99  1.78‒47.85  0.017 
Schooling 9‒11 years (ref. 12+ years)  1.60  0.33‒7.18  0.543 
Moderate/high risk of crack/cocaine useb (ref. low risk)  8.60  1.44‒54.91  0.018 
Low HIV knowledge (ref. high)  3.02  0.83‒11.52  0.094 
Ever transactional sex: yes (ref. no)  1.05  0.25‒4.35  0.945 
Use of industrial fillers: yes (ref. no)  3.40  0.56‒18.45  0.158 
Binge drinking: yes (ref. no)  3.34  0.70‒25.55  0.172 

aOR, Adjusted Odds Ratio; CI, Confidence Interval.

a

Adjusted for race, transactional sex, fillers, and binge drinking.

b

Measured by the Alcohol, Smoking and Substance Involvement Screening Test (ASSIST); score range: 0‒12, moderate/high risk > 2.

c

Includes Indigenous and Asian. Residual analysis tested by Hosmer-Lemeshow (p = 0.101) (Suppl. Fig. 1).

Discussion

More than half of young trans women living with HIV in our study were unaware of their status. Furthermore, many recently acquired HIV, suggesting ongoing incident cases that are often underestimated by prevalence studies alone.25 Young trans women also had a high burden of bSTIs. Characteristics of participants with a new HIV diagnosis were younger age, residence outside Rio de Janeiro’s metropolitan core, and the presence of intersecting vulnerabilities, including industrial filler use, engagement in sex work, and low educational attainment. The multivariable models identified educational attainment and moderate/high crack/cocaine use risk as key predictors of new HIV diagnoses, with those aged 18‒19 years old exhibiting the highest risk of a new HIV infection.

To our knowledge, this is the first study of new HIV infections among young trans women in a low- and middle-income country. Brazil is the largest country in South America, which is one of few regions globally with a rising HIV epidemic, where the highest burden falls on youth. This study points to significant unmet HIV prevention need for young trans women in Brazil. Despite high rates of prior HIV testing, many remained unaware of their status and/or not engaged in HIV prevention and care. Post-test counseling and referrals may be ineffective at linking young trans women to HIV prevention and treatment. Younger age, crack/cocaine use, and lower educational attainment were key predictors of new HIV diagnosis. These factors reflect a syndemic interplay of substance use, economic instability, and structural barriers to education, all of which exacerbate HIV vulnerability among young trans women.11,26,27 Systemic barriers, including stigma, transphobia, inadequate provider training, and limited access to gender-affirming care may further hinder engagement with HIV prevention and treatment services for young trans women.28

The association between less education and new HIV diagnoses align with broader evidence linking educational disparities to HIV vulnerability among trans populations. Other Brazilian studies have found a high percentage of low educational attainment among trans women and an association with high HIV prevalence.5,29 Low education has also been associated with low PrEP adherence in the PrEParadas study, which was a Brazilian trans-specific PrEP demonstration project.30 Lower educational attainment reduces job opportunities, creating economic insecurity and reliance on informal economies such as sex work, which was prevalent among those with a new HIV diagnosis in our sample. A large Brazilian cohort study of 22.7 million low-income individuals analyzed over 9-years (2007‒2015) found that conditional cash transfers (Bolsa Família) significantly reduced AIDS-related morbidity and mortality in highly vulnerable populations.31 In addition, among adult men who have sex with men and trans and non-binary persons living in Brazil enrolled in a cross-sectional online study advertised on dating apps and social media from May to September 2021, there was a direct link between food insecurity and non-adherence to PrEP and ART use.32

Brazil has a Universal Health System (SUS) that provides free and comprehensive healthcare to all people living in the country. SUS has played a crucial role in the HIV response by ensuring widespread access to HIV testing, prevention, and treatment, including universal access to ART and PrEP.33 Yet, many people from sexual and gender minorities face significant barriers to healthcare, including discrimination, stigma, lack of culturally competent care, and fear of mistreatment, all of which ultimately impact their health and well-being.34–36 Geographic disparities were also present in our data as many young trans women lived far from centers of affirming healthcare, reducing access to HIV prevention and care.11,37 In our sample, nearly 10% of participants with a new HIV diagnosis reported industrial filler use, a marker of engagement with unregulated cosmetic providers, a practice that is usually linked to social, medical, and economic constraints, including lack of access to transitioning procedures and healthcare avoidance.38,39 Basic HIV and sexual health education is needed among young trans women to improve their HIV knowledge and potentially reduce their sexual risk behaviors.

This study has some limitations. Due to the cross-sectional design, we cannot infer causality and temporality. The sample size also limits statistical power and the precision of estimates, particularly for subgroup analysis, and may reduce generalizability. In addition, no formal correction for multiple testing was applied, and findings should be interpreted with caution. The study was intentionally designed to enroll young trans women not yet engaged in HIV prevention or care, which may further limit generalizability to other trans populations. Despite these limitations, a key strength of the study is that it was specifically designed to reach a population that is underrepresented in research and for whom data remain scarce in our setting. As such, these findings provide valuable evidence to inform prevention and care strategies for this population.

This study reinforces that HIV disparities among young trans women are rooted in structural inequities that shape individual risk behaviors and limit access to HIV prevention and care. Tailored interventions must address the intersection of social factors and structural needs to effectively reach this population.

Data sharing statement

A complete de-identified dataset sufficient to reproduce the primary study findings will be made available upon request to the corresponding author, following approval of a concept sheet summarizing the analyses to be done.

Author's contribution

EMJ, VGV, BG, and ECW conceived and designed the BeT study. EMJ, CC, BG, and ECW conceived and supervised the current analysis and manuscript preparation. EMJ, CC, and ECW reviewed the literature, interpreted the findings, and drafted the manuscript. CRVC and IBM were responsible for the study coordination and data acquisition. TW, CA, and LM provided important intellectual content to the study design and data interpretation. CS, NB and CC had access to raw data and verified the data. CS and NB did the statistical analyses. SLMT did the recency experiments. SLMT, RIM, SWC and BH were involved in revising the manuscript for important intellectual content. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. EMJ, CC, BG, and ECW had final responsibility for the decision to submit for publication.

Funding

This work was supported by the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development and the National Institutes of Health as the Prevention and Treatment through a Comprehensive Care Continuum for HIV-affected Adolescents in Resource Constrained Settings sponsor (grants UG3HD096914 and UH3HD096914). The sponsor had no role in the design and conduct of the study; collection, management, analysis, and interpretation of the data; preparation, review, or approval of the manuscript; and decision to submit the manuscript for publication. BG was financed in part by CNPq (#313265/2023-2) and Carlos Chagas Filho Foundation for Research Support in the State of Rio de Janeiro (FAPERJ #E.26/200.946/2022). TST was financed in part by CNPq (#304417/2025-4 and #405558/2025-2), FAPERJ (#E-26/201.270/2022). EMJ was financed in part by FAPERJ (E-26/210.072/2025) and CNPq (408880/2025-2).

Conflicts of interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank all study participants. The BeT study team: Ana Carolina Figueiredo, Andressa Araujo, Beatriz Grinsztejn, Brenda Hoagland, Camila Mattos Santos, Carolina Ribeiro de Arsolino, Carolina Coutinho, Claudia M. da Silva, Cristina M. Jalil, Cristiane Castro, Daniel Bezerra, Daniel Waite, Eduardo Carvalheira, Eduardo Peixoto, Edilene Bastos, Emilia M. Jalil, Erin C. Wilson, Flavia Lessa, Giovanna Costa, Isabele Barbosa Moura, Jose Roberto Granjeiro, Katia S. M. Derrico, Iasmim Garrido, Laylla Monteiro, Luana Marins, Luiz Ricardo S. Camacho, Marcella Feitosa, Marcos Davi, Mayara Secco, Natalia Ibiapino Proenca, Renata Bastos, Rita de Cassia O. Cockrane, Robson Silva, Ronaldo I. Moreira, Sandra W. Cardoso, Sandro Nazer, Tania Krstic, Thaylla Warggas, Thiago da Silva Torres, Valdilea G. Veloso, Valeria Ribeiro.

References
[1]
S.D. Baral, T. Poteat, S. Strömdahl, A.L. Wirtz, T.E. Guadamuz, C. Beyrer.
Worldwide burden of HIV in transgender women: a systematic review and meta-analysis.
Lancet Infect Dis, 13 (2013), pp. 214-222
[2]
W. McFarland, P. Wesson, C. Turner, J. Lin, M.A.S.M. Veras, H. Yan, et al.
High HIV incidence among young and racial/ethnic minority transgender women in San Francisco: results of a longitudinal cohort study.
J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr, 84 (2020), pp. e7-e10
[3]
H. Basilio.
Trump team guts AIDS-eradication programme and slashes HIV research grants.
[4]
UNAIDS.
Fact Sheet – Latin America.
[5]
B. Grinsztejn, E.M. Jalil, L. Monteiro, L. Velasque, R.I. Moreira, A.C.F. Garcia, Transcender Study Team.
Unveiling of HIV dynamics among transgender women: a respondent-driven sampling study in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Lancet HIV, 4 (2017), pp. e169-e176
[6]
Brasil. Ministério da Saúde.
Painel PrEP.
Ministério da Saúde, Secretaria de Vigilância em Saúde e Ambiente (SVSA), (2025),
[7]
V.G. Veloso, C.F. Cáceres, B. Hoagland, R.I. Moreira, H. Vega-Ramírez, K.A. Konda, et al.
ImPrEP Study Group. Same-day initiation of oral pre-exposure prophylaxis among gay, bisexual, and other cisgender men who have sex with men and transgender women in Brazil, Mexico, and Peru (ImPrEP): a prospective, single-arm, open-label, multicentre implementation study.
Lancet HIV, 10 (2023), pp. e84-e96
[8]
K.A. Konda, T.S. Torres, G. Mariño, A. Ramos, R.I. Moreira, I.C. Leite, ImPrEP Study Group.
Factors associated with long-term HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis engagement and adherence among transgender women in Brazil, Mexico and Peru: results from the ImPrEP study.
J Int AIDS Soc, 25 (2022),
[9]
T. Poteat, M. Malik, A. Scheim, A. Elliott.
HIV prevention among transgender populations: knowledge gaps and evidence for action.
Curr HIV/AIDS Rep, 14 (2017), pp. 141-152
[10]
M.J. Mimiaga, J.M.W. Hughto, K.B. Biello, C.M. Santostefano, L.M. Kuhns, S.L. Reisner, et al.
Longitudinal analysis of syndemic psychosocial problems predicting HIV risk behavior among a multicity prospective cohort of sexually active young transgender women in the United States.
J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr, 81 (2019), pp. 184-192
[11]
J.T. Parsons, N. Antebi-Gruszka, B.M. Millar, D. Cain, S. Gurung.
Syndemic conditions, HIV transmission risk behavior, and transactional sex among transgender women.
AIDS Behav, 22 (2018), pp. 2056-2067
[12]
T. Poteat, A. Scheim, J. Xavier, S. Reisner, S. Baral.
Global epidemiology of HIV infection and related syndemics affecting transgender people.
J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr, 72 (2016), pp. S210-S219
[13]
E.M. Jalil, E. Wilson, L. Monteiro, T. Varggas, I. Moura, T.S. Torres, et al.
BeT Team. A peer-led digital intervention to reduce HIV prevention and care disparities among young Brazilian transgender women (The BeT Study): protocol for an intervention study.
JMIR Res Protoc, 12 (2023),
[14]
W. Grant-McAuley, E. Klock, O. Laeyendecker, E. Piwowar-Manning, E. Wilson, W. Clarke, et al.
HPTN 071 (PopART) study team. Evaluation of multi-assay algorithms for identifying individuals with recent HIV infection: HPTN 071 (PopART).
PLoS One, 16 (2021),
[15]
C.M. Jalil, S.L.M. Teixeira, C. Coutinho, S.C. Nazer, E. Carvalheira, B. Hoagland, et al.
Impact of COVID-19 pandemic on HIV testing, recent infections, and annualized incidence among cisgender men who have sex with men and transgender women in Brazil.
J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr, 98 (2025), pp. 12-19
[16]
T.S. Torres, S.L.M. Teixeira, B. Hoagland, K.A. Konda, M. Derrico, R.I. Moreira, et al.
ImPrEP Seroincidence study group. Recent HIV infection and annualized HIV incidence rates among sexual and gender minorities in Brazil and Peru (ImPrEP seroincidence study): a cross-sectional, multicenter study.
Lancet Reg Health Am, 28 (2023),
[17]
T.J. Ballard, A.W. Kepple, C. Cafiero.
The food insecurity experience scale: developing a global standard for monitoring hunger worldwide, Technical Paper, (2013),
[18]
World Health Organization.
The Alcohol, Smoking and Substance Involvement Screening Test (ASSIST).
[19]
W.H. Oglesby, S.A. Alemagno.
Psychometric properties of an HIV knowledge scale administered with populations at high risk for HIV infection.
Health Promot Pract, 14 (2013), pp. 859-867
[20]
S.C. Kalichman, L.C. Simbayi.
HIV testing attitudes, AIDS stigma, and voluntary HIV counselling and testing in a black township in Cape Town, South Africa.
Sex Transm Infect., 79 (2003), pp. 442-447
[21]
K. Bush, D.R. Kivlahan, M.B. McDonell, S.D. Fihn, K.A. Bradley.
The AUDIT alcohol consumption questions (AUDIT-C): an effective brief screening test for problem drinking.
Arch Intern Med, 158 (1998), pp. 1789
[22]
G.D. Zimet, N.W. Dahlem, S.G. Zimet, G.K. Farley.
The multidimensional scale of perceived social support.
J Pers Assess, 52 (1988), pp. 30-41
[23]
A. Prins, M.J. Bovin, D.J. Smolenski, B.P. Marx, R. Kimerling, M.A. Jenkins-Guarnieri, et al.
The Primary care PTSD screen for DSM-5 (PC-PTSD-5): development and evaluation within a veteran primary care sample.
J Gen Intern Med, 31 (2016), pp. 1206-1211
[24]
K. Kroenke, R.L. Spitzer, J.B.W. Williams, B. Löwe.
An ultra-brief screening scale for anxiety and depression: the PHQ-4.
Psychosomatics, 50 (2009), pp. 613-621
[25]
T.A. Peterman, A.A. Zaidi, J. Wroten.
Decreasing prevalence hides a high HIV incidence: miami.
[26]
L.S. Magalhães, K.C. Dos Santos, B.V. Diniz E Silva, G.F. Silva Filho, G.R. Costa E Silva, R.A. Guimarães, et al.
Cocaine/crack and cannabis use among transgender women in Goiás, Central Brazil.
PLoS One, 19 (2024),
[27]
J.C. Da Mota, S. Sperandei, R.B. De Boni, I. Dourado, M.A.D.S.M. Veras, F.I Bastos.
Multiple substance uses and associated factors in transgender women and travestis: findings from the TransOdara Study.
Brazil. Rev Bras Epidemiol., 27 (2024),
[28]
B.O. Leite, D.S. De Medeiros, L. Magno, F.I. Bastos, C. Coutinho, A.M. Brito, et al.
Association between gender-based discrimination and medical visits and HIV testing in a large sample of transgender women in northeast Brazil.
Int J Equity Health, 20 (2021), pp. 199
[29]
R.L. Batista, E.D.R. Verduguez, M. Inacio, F.S. Cunha, M.D. Marques, N.L.R.A. Gomes, et al.
Impact of schooling in the HIV/AIDS prevalence among Brazilian transgender women.
Arch Endocrinol Metab, 64 (2020), pp. 369-373
[30]
E.M. Jalil, T.S. Torres, P.M. Luz, L. Monteiro, R.I. Moreira, C.R.V. Castro, et al.
PrEParadas Study Team 1. Low PrEP adherence despite high retention among transgender women in Brazil: the PrEParadas study.
J Int AIDS Soc, 25 (2022),
[31]
A.F. Silva, I. Dourado, I. Lua, G.S. Jesus, N.S. Guimarães, G.A.S. Morais, et al.
Income determines the impact of cash transfers on HIV/AIDS: cohort study of 22.7 million Brazilians.
Nat Commun, 15 (2024), pp. 1307
[32]
P.M. Luz, T.S. Torres, V.C. Matos, G.G. Costa, B. Hoagland, C. Pimenta, et al.
Socio-economic status and adherence to HIV preventive and therapeutic interventions: exploring the mediating role of food insecurity among men who have sex with men and transgender and non-binary persons from Brazil.
J Int AIDS Soc, 28 (2025),
[33]
E.A. Melo, I. Maksud, A.R. Cuidado.
HIV/Aids e atenção primária no Brasil: desafio para a atenção no Sistema Único de Saúde?.
Rev Panam Salud Publica, 42 (2018),
[34]
M.L. Hatzenbuehler, M.R. Lattanner, S. McKetta, J.E. Pachankis.
Structural stigma and LGBTQ+ health: a narrative review of quantitative studies.
Lancet Public Health, 9 (2024), pp. e109-e127
[35]
A.A. Reis, H.R.D. Carvalho.
Primary Health Care in Brazil and the LGBTI+ population: an integrative review.
Saude Debate, 47 (2023),
[36]
A.B. Costa, H.T. Da Rosa Filho, P.F. Pase, A.M.V. Fontanari, R.F. Catelan, A. Mueller, et al.
Healthcare needs of and access barriers for Brazilian transgender and gender diverse people.
J Immigr Minor Health, 20 (2018), pp. 115-123
[37]
E.C. Wilson.
Stalled progress in addressing HIV among trans women in San Francisco, California USA.
International AIDS Society Annual Meeting,
[38]
T. Poteat, S.L. Reisner, A. Radix.
HIV epidemics among transgender women.
Curr Opin HIV AIDS, 9 (2014), pp. 168-173
[39]
E. Wilson, J. Rapues, H. Jin, H.F Raymond.
The use and correlates of illicit silicone or “fillers” in a population-based sample of transwomen, San Francisco, 2013.
J Sex Med, 11 (2014), pp. 1717-1724

For the BeT study team.

Copyright © 2026. Sociedade Brasileira de Infectologia
Download PDF
The Brazilian Journal of Infectious Diseases
Article options
Tools
Supplemental materials